Hey Dave/Plasma,
Another idea I had for the forum was a more detailed section regarding players being banned, and users reporting players. The layout is pretty straight forward.
First, we have a section for players to appeal a ban. That would stay as is. Perhaps rename it to that "Appeal a Ban". If a user posts in that section, he would be required to post his Steam ID and a reason for the appeal, and it would be reviewed. The ban would not be lifted until it was discussed with the admin who placed the ban.
Second, a section for reporting players. Provide a detailed description of how to submit a ticket for review. Imgur screenshot, a demo, a video on YouTube, Steam ID's, etc, as much detail as possible. From there, we would edit the title of the thread. Example:
"Axon - Aimbot!"
"i went to spec and recorded a video of axon sniping getting 100x headshots he said he didnt hack but omfg this is crazy plzzz ban"
Admin responds: On review of your video, I have determined that this player is legit. Thank you for your ticket, and have fun at HyperionGaming!
Admin edits thread title: "[NO BAN] Axon - Aimbot!"
And vice versa, rename thread to "[BANNED] Axon - Aimbot!" if the proof is legit.
This is a good way for players to see that something is being done when an issue arises. And is also a bit more clear to current users who have been banned, on how to generate an appeal.
This could be added to the MOTD as (example) "Report hackers / ass-hattery on the forums." - "Banned? Appeal it at HyperionGaming.org"